George Sand, the French writer, said: “Guard well within yourself that treasure, kindness. Know how to give without hesitation, how to lose without regret, how to acquire without meanness.”
Kindness is my motto, it’s my motivation, it’s what I strive towards. My daughter says I’m a goody-goody. She’s 13 and has to deal with way more than I ever did at her age. So if she wants to think her mom is a goody-goody, fine by me. She could call me worse.
It’s just that after 43 years of hanging around, I feel that all good stuff in life twirls out from the circle of kindness. It’s like watching cotton candy floss being spun in front of your eyes when you were a kid. Yummy strands of sugar (kindness) which become flossy glossy puffballs to which everything sticks (laughter, joy, comfort, understanding, compassion); and when you let it melt in your mouth, it transforms itself into something else entirely (satisfaction, happiness, fulfillment).
If I’m to heed Sand’s advice on guarding that precious treasure of kindness inside myself , I’m two-thirds of the way there: I can give without hesitation, I can acquire without meanness. I do those things with my eyes closed. But losing without regret is something I haven’t mastered. I hope that if I do live to be 102, I can look back on my life and know I was able to accept losses in my life with no regrets. But I’m eons away from scoring a kindness hat-trick.
We are undergoing a major change in our family life. As of tomorrow, my children, G & P, will both live with Mr. C. & I full time. This is big. It’s so big that it deserves to be shouted out! As you know, dear Reader, since the separation several years ago (has it been six years already?), P & G have been living the nomadic divorced-family life of one week with one parent, the next week with the other parent. During the course of those six years, both my kids have struggled with this, each in their own way: I spent many nights consoling my daughter G over the phone when she would cry and beg for me to come and get her because she missed me; with my son P, the pain of being separated from me became too much, and he eventually lived with me for a short time, and again with Mr. C. and myself during a time last year. They’re well-cared for at their father’s, but eventually, they wanted to live in one house and be like their friends. And the long-standing ache of living half the time in a place that they felt they didn’t belong took its toll: G had a break-down at the start of the school year and chose to live with us (which came as a huge surprise to me, as the past year has been very difficult for her and I). Mind you, G made sure to preface her decision with “It’s not because I miss you or anything like that.” Ok, if you say so….. With G, you have to be a very good reader-between-the-lines in order to understand and feel what’s truly in her heart.
For P, he’s been on the fence for a long time, sensitive to his dad’s feelings, so when he finally came to us a few weeks ago with his decision to live with us, we were very happy, but we all knew it would cause conflict and heartache. Both of my children knew their father would feel hurt, and they’ve tried in their own way to make it easier for him, with wisdom and grace beyond their childhood years. This makes me so proud of them and so profoundly sad for them all at once.
To say that I’m happy to have my children with me full-time is an understatement. My heart is so full, I can barely articulate it without tears coming to my eyes. So why the regrets? This should be a happy time, a triumphant time. And it is. It’s all that and more. I have my children with me again, and with Mr. C. by my side, we are a family, a true family.
The regret comes from a crystallized moment in this whole sad story: I regret that when I left their father, I didn’t stand my ground and bring the children with me, in the face of his empty threats that he made in painful anger. I wasn’t able to see past my own hurt to know that his reactions would pass. I regret that I took the easy way to avoid conflict with him and the legal battle that would have ensued. What children need most in times of conflict is stability, and I was sure that stability meant for them to alternate between their father and I, because we both loved them, we both were able to care well for them, and we both wanted what was best for them. The phenomenon of shared custody in divorced families is relatively new, maybe 20 years or so. In theory, it’s a good plan, I believe that. But in practice, it serves only to alleviate some of the guilt that parents feel about causing this upheaval in the lives of their children. Most importantly, the children are uprooted every week or so to live like gypsies. For them, it’s like shifting sand, very little stability and constancy, always having to adjust.
A regret is a painful self-reproach, something that one wishes to have done differently. Divorce is alot like grieving. There are stages and phases, and sometimes it feels like you’re going around in circles. My regret is not that I divorced; I think it takes courage to face circumstances that you know are not salvageable and to make hard choices that will have serious consequences on everyone involved. My regret is that in the face of making that really hard choice and being strong, in the interest of being as fair as I could possibly be and not cause any, and I mean ANY, financial hardship on their father, I let my fear of his anger and my pathological avoidance of conflict dictate my heart when it came to my children at that crucial time in their lives. Sometimes, I feel I should have fought for my children, so that they would have lived with me, not because I’m a better parent than their father, but as it became evident in the years that followed, they needed me in their lives full-time. That’s what would’ve been best for them; instead I believed in feeding them the rhetoric that having two loving homes was the way to go. As it turns out, kids of divorced families don’t care about having two homes: they only want one, they only need one. P expressed his frustrations about kids in his class telling him how lucky he was to have two houses: he doesn’t see it as luck, for him it’s a burden. One night, as he poured out his heart, he said to me: ”Divorced families should live in one house with four floors so that everybody could live together.” I hugged him and said I thought that was a great idea, knowing that he wouldn’t feel that way if there had been violence and abuse in our past. But in his 11-year-old eyes, in all of his budding wisdom, and knowing that he will never have his greatest wish of having his parents be together ever again, his solution to this unsolveable dilemna was a wishful reunification on a different wavelength.
Those losses that my children experienced in the past six years, because of decisions taken without their input or permission, losses that they were made to feel because of choices made for them…… that’s what I regret.
Now here come the hard questions:
Is it possible that one can never experience a loss at the moment that it’s occurring without feeling any regret?
Does being able to lose without regret, as Sand advises, does that come only later (and maybe much later)?
Perhaps it’s necessary to regret losses as they are happening.
And here’s one to wrap your head around: Maybe it’s impossible to not regret your losses until you’ve regretted them.

What if the biggest kindness that you can do for yourself is to travel the path of regretting a loss, so that you can come to a point where you can rejoice over that loss?
I think I have a shot at that kindness hat-trick after all……..
Love,
Chantal











